The Good Guys Heating & Cooling
Appleton, WI Furnace Replacement · 105+ yrs
ⓘVouched Score is calculated from publicly available signals: Google rating & review count, Yelp rating, BBB grade, review sentiment, years in business, local search ranking, and provider website content. Not a guarantee of service quality.Embed this score
⏱ 105+ years in business
Review sentiment: 85/100
Overview
Furnace replacement work includes gas-furnace installs and estimator-led changeout proposals. The Good Guys state they perform combustion analysis with a combustion analyzer and CO checks. The Good Guys report a fifth-generation history since the 1920s. Appleton's cold winters make proper combustion commissioning and correct venting especially important.
The Good Guys Heating & Cooling handles gas furnace replacement and oil-to-gas conversions in Appleton. Combustion analysis: the company states it performs complete combustion analysis and CO checks on gas equipment. Free estimates: they advertise free estimates and online estimator scheduling. Emergency response: they list 24/7 emergency service and same-day availability.
Score breakdown
Editorial Review
66
46%
Google Rating
90
17%
Local Search Rank
70
9%
Review Sentiment
85
15%
Years in Business
100
4%
Review Volume
59
9%
Composite of public-record signals (BBB, license records), customer review signals (Google, Yelp), and editorial assessment of provider profile. See full methodology →
Pros
Strengths
- High Google rating (4.7★ across 150+ reviews)
- Long-established (105+ years in business)
When to choose them
- You need same-day furnace replacement
- You need same-day or after-hours service
- You need to finance the work
- You value a long-tenured local operator (105+ years in business)
Services
Service area
Published pricing
Discounts
-
50% off
As published: 50% off"…ups for the life of your new equipment, as low as 50% off (yes really!). If you're comparing companies ask…"
Pricing model
-
Flat-rate pricing
As published: Flat-rate pricing"…ing the day it is always appreciated if possible. Flat Rate Pricing When we know what repairs are needed, we can give…"
Estimates
-
Free estimates
As published: Free estimates"…e-Ups Repair/Diagnostic Service Call No Pressure, Free Estimates Free Second Opinions Financing Options Tax Credit…"
Contact & hours
📞
🌐
✉️
📍
🕒
8:00a to 4:30p (Mon-Fri)
Frequently asked questions
What are the pros of The Good Guys Heating & Cooling?
Based on public records and customer reviews: High Google rating (4.7★ across 150+ reviews); Long-established (105+ years in business); Emergency response: 24/7; Financing available; Free estimates.
When should I choose The Good Guys Heating & Cooling?
Choose them if: You need same-day furnace replacement; You need same-day or after-hours service; You need to finance the work; You value a long-tenured local operator (105+ years in business).
What is the Vouched Score for The Good Guys Heating & Cooling?
74/100. Top contributing signals: Years In Business 100/100, Google Rating 90/100+ Review Sentiment 85/100. The score blends public-record signals (BBB, license records), customer review signals (Google, Yelp), and editorial assessment.
How long has The Good Guys Heating & Cooling been in business?
The Good Guys Heating & Cooling has been operating for 105+ years in Appleton, WI.
How can I contact The Good Guys Heating & Cooling?
Call The Good Guys Heating & Cooling at +1-920-734-1436. Address: 4450 W Greenville Dr, Appleton, WI 54913, USA.
What does furnace replacement service typically cost when working with a Appleton, WI provider like The Good Guys Heating & Cooling?
Full gas furnace replacement typically runs $3,000–$6,500, and high-efficiency condensing furnace runs $4,500–$9,500 in Appleton, Wisconsin. These are area-wide market estimates, not The Good Guys Heating & Cooling's quotes. For an exact price, request a written estimate from The Good Guys Heating & Cooling.
What pricing terms does The Good Guys Heating & Cooling publish on their website?
The Good Guys Heating & Cooling's website publishes: 50% off, Flat-rate pricing, Free estimates. Promotions and plans change — confirm currently-available terms with The Good Guys Heating & Cooling before acting.
Does The Good Guys Heating & Cooling do Furnace Replacement in Appleton, WI?
Yes. The Good Guys Heating & Cooling lists Furnace Replacement among its services and serves Appleton, WI and Replacement Appleton, WI. Call +1-920-734-1436 for a quote.
Does The Good Guys Heating & Cooling do Emergency HVAC Service in Appleton, WI?
Yes. The Good Guys Heating & Cooling lists Emergency HVAC Service among its services and serves Appleton, WI and Replacement Appleton, WI. Call +1-920-734-1436 for a quote.
Compare with nearby providers
| Provider | Vouched | Years | |
|---|---|---|---|
The Good Guys Heating & Cooling (this company) ⭐ Honest Replace-vs-Repair · ⭐ Combustion-Safe Installation · ⭐ Gas Furnace Replacement |
74/100 | 4.7★ (150+) | 105+ |
| 75/100 | 5.0★ (80+) | 10+ | |
Blount Heating & Air Conditioning Inc ⭐ Best Manufacturer-Authorized Installer |
79/100 | 4.9★ (155+) | 54+ |
Listed in
Explore more
Profile last updated July 26, 2026.