J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.
Erie, PA Furnace Replacement · #3 of 4 · 74+ yrs
ⓘVouched Score is calculated from publicly available signals: Google rating & review count, Yelp rating, BBB grade, review sentiment, years in business, local search ranking, and provider website content. Not a guarantee of service quality.Embed this score
⏱ 74+ years in business
Review sentiment: 88/100
Overview
J.J. Agnello lists furnace replacement and full-system changeouts among core services. The company lists Lennox Premier Dealer status dating to 1966. J.J. Agnello was founded in 1952, showing 70+ years serving Erie homes. Erie winters demand robust heating solutions, and the site notes same-day response for urgent heating needs.
Furnace replacement specialist focused on gas furnace changeouts for Erie-area homes. Lennox Premier Dealer status is listed, including dealer-tier association. The website lists financing options and same-day emergency response. The company traces its history back to 1952, serving Erie for 70+ years.
Score breakdown
Erie, PA Furnace Replacement average is 79/100. Ranks #3 of 4 listed Furnace Replacement providers in Erie, PA.
Editorial Review
72
46%
Google Rating
93
17%
Local Search Rank
66
9%
Review Sentiment
88
15%
Years in Business
100
4%
Review Volume
62
9%
Composite of public-record signals (BBB, license records), customer review signals (Google, Yelp), and editorial assessment of provider profile. See full methodology →
vs. Erie average
| Signal | J.J. Agnello Heating … | Erie avg | Delta |
|---|---|---|---|
| Vouched Score | 78/100 | 79/100 | -1 vs avg |
| Google rating | 4.8★ | 4.8★ | matches city average |
| Review volume | 200+ | 655+ | -454 vs avg |
| Years in business | 74+ | 36+ | +38 vs avg |
Pros
Strengths
- High Google rating (4.8★ across 200+ reviews)
- Long-established (74+ years in business)
When to choose them
- You need same-day furnace replacement
- You need furnace + AC system replacement
- You need high-efficiency furnace replacement
- You need same-day or after-hours service
- You want manufacturer-warranty installation work
Services
Service area
Erie, PAhome
Contact & hours
📞
🌐
✉️
📍
🕒
Call for hours
Frequently asked questions
What are the pros of J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.?
Based on public records and customer reviews: High Google rating (4.8★ across 200+ reviews); Long-established (74+ years in business); Authorized Lennox Premier Dealer; Emergency response: same-day; Financing available; Specializes in furnace replacement.
When should I choose J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.?
Choose them if: You need same-day furnace replacement; You need furnace + AC system replacement; You need high-efficiency furnace replacement; You need same-day or after-hours service; You want manufacturer-warranty installation work.
What is the Vouched Score for J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.?
78/100. Top contributing signals: Years In Business 100/100, Google Rating 93/100+ Review Sentiment 88/100. The score blends public-record signals (BBB, license records), customer review signals (Google, Yelp), and editorial assessment.
How long has J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. been in business?
J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. has been operating for 74+ years in Erie, PA.
How can I contact J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.?
Call J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. at +1-814-453-5096. Address: 1602 Liberty St, Erie, PA 16502, USA.
What does furnace replacement service typically cost when working with a Erie, PA provider like J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.?
Full gas furnace replacement typically runs $2,600–$5,600, and high-efficiency condensing furnace runs $3,900–$8,200 in Erie, Pennsylvania. These are area-wide market estimates, not J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.'s quotes. For an exact price, request a written estimate from J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc..
What pricing terms does J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. publish on their website?
J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc.'s website publishes: No hidden fees. Promotions and plans change — confirm currently-available terms with J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. before acting.
Does J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. do Furnace Replacement in Erie, PA?
Yes. J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. lists Furnace Replacement among its services and serves Erie, PA and Replacement Erie, PA. Call +1-814-453-5096 for a quote.
Does J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. do Commercial HVAC in Erie, PA?
Yes. J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. lists Commercial HVAC among its services and serves Erie, PA and Replacement Erie, PA. Call +1-814-453-5096 for a quote.
Does J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. do Emergency HVAC Service in Erie, PA?
Yes. J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. lists Emergency HVAC Service among its services and serves Erie, PA and Replacement Erie, PA. Call +1-814-453-5096 for a quote.
Compare with nearby providers
| Provider | Vouched | Years | |
|---|---|---|---|
J.J. Agnello Heating & Air Conditioning, Inc. (this company) ⭐ Furnace + AC Changeout · ⭐ Commercial Furnace Replacement · ⭐ Manufacturer-Authorized Installer |
78/100 | 4.8★ (200+) | 74+ |
| 68/100 | 4.8★ (50+) | 21+ | |
Nerthling’s Heating & Air Conditioning ⭐ Highest Vouched Score · ⭐ Best for Gas Furnace Replacement · ⭐ Best NATE-Certified Installer |
93/100 | 4.9★ (1,635+) | 74+ |
| 74/100 | 4.7★ (400+) | 19+ |
Listed in
Explore more
Profile last updated July 24, 2026.